Uber and Lyft Accidents in NYC: Who's Liable?

After most crashes, you at least know who to call. After a rideshare crash, many people don't even know who the other party is — you were a passenger in someone else's car, you may only have the driver's first name from an app, you don't know who insures the vehicle, and the company whose app you used says the driver isn't its employee.

‍

After an Uber or Lyft crash, more than one party may be responsible — the rideshare driver, another driver, the rideshare company, and sometimes the vehicle's owner. Because a trip that originates in New York City is governed by the NYC Taxi & Limousine Commission rather than New York's statewide rideshare law, the TLC commercial policy on the vehicle usually provides the primary coverage, subject to any additional or excess coverage the rideshare company maintains.

‍

This guide explains why NYC works differently, who can be held responsible, which policy pays and in what order, what applies if you were the driver, and what to do now. Kleban Law Group handles motor vehicle claims on contingency from Valley Stream across Nassau, Queens, Brooklyn, Long Island, and NYC.

‍

Why NYC Rideshare Accidents Don't Follow the Rules You've Read About

‍

If you've already read about Uber and Lyft accidents online, you've probably seen the “three period” framework: coverage that switches on and off with the app, with $1.25 million kicking in during an active trip. That comes from New York's state rideshare law — the Transportation Network Company law, Vehicle and Traffic Law Article 44-B. Outside the city it sets roughly $75,000/$150,000 for bodily injury and $25,000 for property damage while a driver is logged in and waiting, rising to $1,250,000 once a ride is accepted or a passenger is aboard.

‍

Here's the part almost every article misses: that state law does not apply to a prearranged trip originating in New York City. The New York State Department of Financial Services says so directly.

‍

Inside the five boroughs, Uber and Lyft drivers are licensed for-hire drivers regulated by the NYC Taxi and Limousine Commission (TLC), and TLC rules govern their insurance instead. The practical upshot is reassuring: a TLC-licensed vehicle must carry commercial liability coverage that is maintained continuously — not coverage that flips on and off with the app. The “was the app on?” fight that dominates rideshare cases elsewhere matters far less here.

‍

One honest boundary: a trip that begins outside the city — in Nassau, on Long Island, in Westchester — may fall under the state rules instead. Where the trip started can matter.

‍

Who Can Be Held Liable for an Uber or Lyft Accident in NYC

‍

The Rideshare Driver

‍

The most common defendant. This is ordinary negligence — speeding, distraction, failure to yield. Fatigue is a real factor in this industry, and the app's own records can speak to how long a driver had been working.

‍

The Vehicle's Owner, if That Isn't the Driver

‍

Under New York's owner-liability rule (VTL §388), a vehicle's owner can be held responsible for the negligence of someone driving it with permission — potentially a second insurance policy, and one that doesn't depend on the independent-contractor argument at all. There's an important limit, though. Many TLC vehicles are leased or rented from fleets rather than owned by the driver, and a federal law — the Graves Amendment — generally shields companies in the business of leasing or renting vehicles from this kind of owner liability (it pre-empts VTL §388). So the owner route tends to help when the driver actually owns the car, not when the vehicle was leased or rented from a leasing company that did nothing wrong itself.

‍

Another Driver

‍

Often the rideshare vehicle wasn't at fault. If another car caused the crash, your claim runs against that driver — and no-fault still applies first (more below). This is also the route for anyone hit by an Uber or Lyft in NYC as a pedestrian or cyclist.

‍

Uber or Lyft Themselves — and Why This Is Harder Than People Assume

‍

Both Uber and Lyft classify their drivers as independent contractors, which they use to resist vicarious liability (being held responsible for a driver's negligence the way an employer would be). The law here is genuinely unsettled. At the trial level, one court sided with Uber in Bongiovi v. Pulla (2024), treating the driver as an independent contractor. But in 2026 an appellate court went the other way in Bandele v. Rasier-NY, LLC (Appellate Division, Second Department), holding that whether an Uber driver is an independent contractor or an employee is a question for the jury — meaning the companies cannot always get these claims dismissed before trial. Claims against Uber or Lyft may also proceed on other theories, such as negligent hiring. It's a moving area, and exactly the kind of question worth putting in front of a lawyer.

‍

The City, the MTA, or Another Third Party

‍

A defective roadway, a dangerous construction zone, or an MTA bus can put a public entity in the picture — which carries a much shorter deadline (see below).

‍

Which Insurance Actually Pays in New York City

‍

No-Fault Comes First — and There's a 30-Day Trap

‍

New York is a no-fault state. An injured passenger generally claims no-fault (also called PIP) benefits from the insurer of the vehicle they were riding in, regardless of who caused the crash, covering basic economic loss up to $50,000 — medical treatment and part of lost earnings. Here's what people miss: the no-fault application must generally be filed within 30 days of the accident, and medical bills submitted within 45 days. Missing these deadlines can cost you the benefits — though if you have a reasonable excuse for the delay, they may still be honored. Don't count on that exception; file as soon as you can. If you're reading this weeks after a crash, this is the most important paragraph on the page.

‍

If you're near the 30-day mark and unsure what's been filed, call us — (866) 263-4529 / (866) CME-4-LAW, free and no obligation.

‍

The TLC Commercial Liability Policy

‍

For injuries beyond what no-fault covers, the liability claim in a city-originating trip generally runs against the commercial policy on the TLC-licensed vehicle — at least $100,000 per person / $300,000 per accident for a standard for-hire vehicle — and potentially the owner's or base's coverage too. Sorting out which policies exist is much of the work, and it's covered by our New York City rideshare accident lawyers.

‍

When You Can Sue for Pain and Suffering

‍

Because this is a motor vehicle case, the no-fault “serious injury” threshold applies: you can only pursue pain and suffering if your injury meets the definition in Insurance Law §5102(d) — death, dismemberment, significant disfigurement, a fracture, permanent loss of use, permanent consequential limitation, or significant limitation of use. It's why two passengers in the same car can end up with very different claims. (See how New York's no-fault system works.)

‍

Uninsured and Underinsured Coverage

‍

If the at-fault vehicle is uninsured or carries too little, UM/UIM coverage — on the rideshare vehicle's policy or your own — may fill the gap. Many people don't realize their own auto policy can help even when they were a passenger in someone else's car.

‍

If You Were Driving for Uber or Lyft: The Black Car Fund

‍

Almost every article on this topic is written for passengers. If you were driving, your situation is different — and better than you may think.

‍

The New York Black Car Fund provides workers'-compensation-style benefits to for-hire drivers injured on the job — medical care and a portion of lost earnings — funded by a small surcharge on passenger fares. Three things to know:

‍

• It pays regardless of who caused the crash. For a driver, it's usually the first and fastest source of help.

• It covers drivers, not passengers.

• It doesn't necessarily end the matter. If someone else's negligence caused your crash, you may also have a claim against that at-fault party, on top of your Black Car Fund benefits. Most drivers don't know this.

‍

Immigration status does not prevent an injured person from pursuing an injury claim in New York — worth stating plainly, because worry about it stops people who have every right to seek help.

‍

Drive for Uber or Lyft and got hurt on the job? You may have a claim in addition to your benefits. We'll explain what you can pursue — (866) 263-4529 / (866) CME-4-LAW, free and no obligation.

‍

What to Do After an Uber or Lyft Accident in NYC

‍

These are the rideshare-specific steps — for the general post-crash checklist, see what to do after a car accident in New York.

‍

• Screenshot the trip in the app immediately — the receipt, the driver's name and photo, the vehicle and plate, the route, and the times. This is the single most important thing on this list. It proves the trip was active and who was driving, and riders routinely lose access to old trip details later.

‍

• Report the crash through the app — but don't give a recorded statement to any insurer before getting advice.

‍

• Photograph the TLC license plate and the diamond-shaped TLC decal — they identify the for-hire vehicle and help trace the owner and base.

‍

• Get the police report number.

‍

• File the no-fault application within 30 days, and get medical attention — being complete about symptoms, including minor ones.

‍

How Long Do You Have to Bring a Claim?

‍

• Three years from the crash for most personal injury claims against a private party (CPLR 214).

‍

• Much shorter if a public entity is involved — an MTA bus, a City vehicle, a defective roadway: a Notice of Claim is generally required within 90 days, with suit within one year and 90 days (GML §50-e / §50-i).

‍

• No-fault is shortest of all — roughly 30 days for the application. It's the deadline most likely to be missed, which is why it's worth repeating.

‍

Frequently Asked Questions

‍

Does Uber or Lyft's insurance cover passengers in New York City?

‍

Two coverages do two different jobs. No-fault (PIP) always applies — regardless of where the trip started — and pays for medical treatment and part of your lost earnings no matter who was at fault. For the liability side, a trip that originates in NYC is covered by the vehicle's TLC commercial policy (a minimum of $100,000 per person / $300,000 per accident; some drivers carry more, though many don't) — not the $1.25 million figure from New York's state rideshare law, which applies to trips originating outside the city.

‍

Can I sue Uber or Lyft directly?

‍

It's difficult but not impossible, and the law is unsettled. Both classify drivers as independent contractors to resist liability; a trial court accepted that in Bongiovi, but in 2026 an appellate court (Bandele v. Rasier-NY) held the employee-versus-contractor question is for a jury. Claims may also proceed on theories like negligent hiring.

‍

Who pays my medical bills after an Uber or Lyft accident?

‍

No-fault (PIP) coverage first — up to $50,000 for medical treatment and part of your lost earnings, regardless of fault. You must file the application within about 30 days.

‍

What if I was hit by an Uber or Lyft as a pedestrian or cyclist?

‍

You'd generally have a no-fault claim for your medical bills and lost earnings, plus a liability claim against whoever was at fault. That framework is the same as any vehicle crash — being hit by a rideshare vehicle mainly changes which insurance policies are involved.

‍

I was driving for Uber or Lyft when I got hurt — what can I claim?

‍

The Black Car Fund provides workers'-comp-style benefits to injured for-hire drivers regardless of fault. If another party caused your crash, you may also have a separate claim against them.

‍

Does it matter whether the driver had a passenger at the time?

‍

Far less than for a trip outside the city. The state rideshare law changes coverage by “period,” but it doesn't apply to trips originating in NYC, where TLC rules require continuous commercial coverage.

‍

The Bottom Line

‍

New York City rideshare crashes don't follow the state rideshare rules most articles describe, and working out who is liable usually means identifying several possible parties and policies — often when you don't even know who owned the vehicle or who insured it.

‍

That's the part we handle. A case review with an experienced rideshare accident lawyer in New York is free, confidential, and no obligation, and if we take your case, you pay nothing unless we win. Call (866) 263-4529 / (866) CME-4-LAW or use the “What is my case worth?” form. We represent injured passengers, drivers, pedestrians, and cyclists across Valley Stream, Nassau County, Queens, Brooklyn, Long Island, and New York City — and you can read how personal injury claims work in New York for the process.

‍